Claim denied or delayed in New Braunfels, TX? Contact the top New Braunfels insurance bad faith attorney today.
When you file an insurance claim after a car crash on I-35, flood damage near the Guadalupe or Comal River, or a hailstorm that tears up your roof, you expect your insurer to pay what your policy promises. Too often, the insurance company drags its feet, asks for the same documents again and again, or offers far less than your losses are worth. Meanwhile, the repair estimates and medical bills keep piling up. Texas law, including the Texas Insurance Code, requires insurers to handle claims fairly and promptly. When they don’t, you have the right to hold them accountable.
At Vendt Accident Attorneys, we stand up to insurance companies that put their profits ahead of the people they insure. With 85 years of combined legal experience, our team reviews your policy in detail, tracks every delay and broken promise, and builds a strong case to show how your insurer failed you. We proudly serve clients in New Braunfels, throughout Comal County, and across Texas, and we are ready to fight for you at the negotiating table or in court. We take on the insurance company so you can focus on your family and getting your life back on track.
Contact us for a free case review and learn how our New Braunfels insurance bad faith attorneys can help you recover the full benefits and compensation you deserve.
What Is Insurance Bad Faith in Texas?
Every insurance policy carries a legal obligation known as the “duty of good faith and fair dealing.” This requires your insurer to investigate your claim honestly, respond within reasonable timeframes, and pay what you are owed without looking for ways to avoid doing so.
When a carrier denies a valid claim, drags out the process, or offers far less than your losses are worth, it is not just bad customer service. It is a violation of Texas law, and you have the right to pursue compensation beyond the original value of your denied claim.
Signs Your Insurer Is Acting in Bad Faith
Bad faith rarely starts with an outright refusal. It usually unfolds through a pattern of delays, misrepresentations, and pressure tactics. These are the warning signs to watch for:
- Unexplained delays: Your claim remains open for months with vague updates and no resolution in sight.
- Misrepresented policy terms: An adjuster applies an exclusion that does not actually fit your situation, counting on you not to push back.
- Pressure to settle fast: You receive a low offer alongside urgency to sign a release before you fully understand your rights.
- Denial without policy support: The insurer refuses your claim but cannot cite a specific provision that justifies the decision.
- No real investigation: A determination is made before anyone from the company reviewed your damage, medical records, or submitted documentation.
If two or more of these describe your situation, speak with an attorney before you respond to the insurer again.
What we see across UM/UIM claims in Comal County is that the injured driver’s own insurer starts acting like the other driver’s insurer. After a crash on I-35 or Highway 46, the carrier questions every treatment and offers a fraction of the medical bills, even though the at-fault driver had little or no coverage. We document the injuries and the policy limits early, and we track every Chapter 542 deadline the carrier misses.
Common Law vs. Statutory Bad Faith in Texas
Texas recognizes two legal frameworks for holding an insurer accountable. Common law bad faith is built on decades of court decisions and requires proving your insurer had no reasonable basis for denying or delaying your claim and knew or should have known it. Statutory bad faith is written law under Chapters 541 and 542 of the Texas Insurance Code, which prohibit specific acts like misrepresenting coverage, failing to promptly investigate, and offering unreasonably low settlements.
|
Common Law Bad Faith |
Statutory Bad Faith |
|
|
Source |
Court decisions |
Texas Insurance Code Ch. 541 & 542 |
|
What You Prove |
No reasonable basis, and the insurer knew or should have known it |
A specific act prohibited by statute |
|
Damages Available |
Actual damages, mental anguish, punitive damages |
Actual damages, up to 3x damages, attorney’s fees |
Both frameworks can apply to the same case. We evaluate every available path and pursue the combination that positions you for the strongest recovery.
UM/UIM and Property Bad Faith Claims in New Braunfels
Uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM coverage) is designed to protect you when the driver who caused your accident carries little or no insurance. Because this payout comes directly from your own insurer’s pocket, carriers routinely dispute injury severity, challenge fault, or push low offers long after their obligation to pay is clear.
Property and homeowners claims follow a similar pattern across Comal and Guadalupe counties. After hail, wind, or flood damage, your insurer may send a biased inspector or rely on creative depreciation methods to justify a reduced settlement. Common excuses used to underpay valid property claims include:
- Mislabeling storm damage as “wear and tear”
- Calling structural damage cosmetic and therefore excluded
- Using depreciation calculations that bear no relation to your actual loss
- Sending inspectors who consistently report less damage than contractors find
Whether the dispute involves your vehicle or your home, we know how these decisions get made, and how to dismantle them.
One pattern we consistently see in New Braunfels property claims is a hail or wind claim where the insurer’s inspector finds far less damage than the roofer who actually climbed on the roof. The carrier then pays for a few shingles or calls the rest wear and tear. We get an independent inspection and line it up against the adjuster’s estimate, because that gap often shows the claim was not fairly investigated.
The Texas Prompt Payment Act Penalty
The Texas Prompt Payment of Claims Act sets mandatory deadlines for every insurer operating in this state. Miss them without a valid reason, and you are entitled to the full claim amount plus 18% annual interest and your attorney’s fees for most claims. Weather-related property claims governed by Chapter 542A carry a lower interest rate. The core deadlines are:
- 15 days to acknowledge your claim after receiving notice
- 15 business days to accept or deny it after receiving all required documentation
- 5 business days to issue payment once a claim is approved
We track every date in your file. Each missed deadline becomes another point of leverage in building your case.
DTPA Treble Damages and the Stowers Doctrine
The Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act (DTPA) allows courts to multiply your recovery when an insurer acts “knowingly,” meaning it was aware its conduct was deceptive and proceeded anyway. When that threshold is met, you can recover up to three times your economic damages.
The Stowers doctrine applies when a third party makes a claim against you after an accident. If that party offers to settle within your policy limits and your insurer refuses, the carrier becomes responsible for any jury verdict that exceeds those limits. Their decision to gamble becomes their financial obligation, not yours.
How We Prove Bad Faith Against Your Insurer
Proving bad faith requires more than a denial letter. It means reconstructing how the decision was made and demonstrating that it was unreasonable, unsupported by your policy, or deliberately designed to harm you.
From the first day, we send a preservation demand, a legal notice requiring the insurer to retain all adjuster notes, internal emails, claim files, and recorded calls. We then send a formal demand letter citing each specific Texas Insurance Code violation in your file, putting the carrier on notice that statutory penalties and attorney’s fees are now on the table.
Through discovery, we pull the full claim file, depose the adjuster under oath, and examine training materials and valuation software outputs like Colossus, a tool carriers use to systematically generate lower settlements. Insurers settle fairly when they know trial is not a bluff. Drawing on Scott M. Broussard’s Texas jury trial experience, we prepare every case as if a New Braunfels jury will decide it.
Call (832) 490-7088 to put that preparation to work for you.
A tactic we see repeatedly is the insurer asking for the same documents over and over, then pointing to the missing paperwork as the reason the claim is still open. We send everything in writing with proof of delivery and keep a timeline, so the delay is documented as the insurer’s choice and not yours.
What a Successful Bad Faith Claim Can Recover
A bad faith lawsuit can produce significantly more than the original amount of your denied claim. Recoverable damages may include:
- The full policy benefits you were originally owed
- 18% annual interest for Prompt Payment Act violations
- Up to three times your economic damages under the DTPA, or your actual damages under Chapter 541
- Compensation for mental anguish caused by the insurer’s conduct
- Punitive damages for egregious or intentional misconduct
- Attorney’s fees and court costs paid by the insurer
The total value of your case depends on the insurer’s specific conduct and the size of your underlying losses, both of which we assess together during your free consultation.
“Mr. Vendt is a very knowledgeable & fair Attorney. I was great and very happy with the help I received. You will not find better council.” – Darren G
How Long You Have to File a Bad Faith Lawsuit in Texas
Texas gives you two years from the date the bad-faith act occurred, or from when you reasonably discovered it, to file a lawsuit. This runs separately from the statute of limitations on your underlying accident or property claim, a distinction that catches many policyholders off guard. The sooner you act, the better your ability to preserve the evidence your case depends on.
What to Do Right Now to Protect Your Claim
Before you respond to the insurance company again, take these steps:
- Save every document: Your full policy, all denial letters, and every piece of written communication with the insurer form the backbone of your case.
- Decline recorded statements: Adjusters are trained to ask questions that reshape your account of events. Do not give one without legal counsel.
- Keep a call log: Record the date, the adjuster’s name, and a summary of every conversation you have with the insurance company.
- Preserve your evidence: Hold onto photos of damage, repair estimates, medical bills, and every receipt connected to your claim.
Once you retain us, we take over all communications with the carrier. You will not have to handle any of it on your own.
Why New Braunfels Residents Choose Vendt Accident Attorneys
Insurance companies come to the table with experienced legal teams, internal claims systems, and denial processes built to protect their bottom line. Our firm makes sure that having an attorney on your side keeps you from ending up on the wrong side of that imbalance. With 85 years of combined legal experience and an office in New Braunfels serving Comal and Guadalupe counties, we know these courts, these carriers, and the tactics used to underpay ordinary Texans.
Founding attorney Frank Vendt, Jr., a former Fort Bend County Bar Association President, leads a team that handles every phase of your case, from the initial consultation through trial. We work entirely on a contingency fee basis: no cost to you unless we win. The fight is ours to carry. You just have to make the call.
Call (832) 490-7088 or contact us online to schedule your free consultation.
“Frank was great to work with. He represented me in a manner that was professional and very efficient. Frank does what he does because he has a passion for justice. I am very appreciative of all that Frank has done for me and I will recommend him to anyone that needs legal representation conducted the ‘right’ way.” – Sharndell Carr
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a Denied Claim Automatically Mean My Insurer Acted in Bad Faith?
Not automatically, but a denial combined with an inadequate investigation, unexplained delay, or misrepresented policy terms can clearly establish bad faith, and that is precisely what we evaluate when reviewing your case.
Can I Still File a Bad Faith Claim After Accepting a Partial Payment?
In most cases, yes. Cashing a partial payment check does not waive your legal rights unless you also signed a full release, which is why no settlement document should be signed without an attorney reviewing it first.
Can I Record Phone Calls with My Insurance Adjuster in Texas?
Texas is a one-party consent state, so you can legally record any call you are participating in, and those recordings can serve as direct evidence of delay, misrepresentation, or pressure tactics used against you.
What if My Insurer Cites a Policy Exclusion to Deny My Claim?
Policy exclusions are frequently misapplied or misread by adjusters. We review your complete policy alongside the denial letter to determine whether the exclusion they cited actually applies to your specific situation. Often, it does not.
Does Bad Faith Law Apply to Third-Party Insurers?
Bad faith claims are most often brought against your own insurer in a first-party context. The Stowers doctrine, however, creates accountability for third-party insurers who refuse a reasonable within-limits settlement demand, leaving their own insured exposed to a verdict above policy limits.